Recruiting 2012

Moderators: greenyellow, UOducksTK1

vagusnerve
Freshman
Posts: 1383
Joined: Tue Feb 02, 2010 12:56 pm

Recruiting 2012

Post by vagusnerve »

I'm not one to go jump off a cliff when things don't seem to be going well.

And CFB recruiting is about the dumbest thing to get worked up about.

So I'm telling you, I say this with almost zero emotion:
The Ducks are getting spanked in recruiting this year and it does not look good. USC is part of it. But there aren't any "top" players left on the board. Swing and a miss is what it looks like from this armchair :P

That's okay. Things go up, things go down, things go around. Right now, it's pretty darn grim for the Ducks.

Feel free to disagree. Or agree. And yes, things might turn around because, hey, it's early. Just don't spam me with platitudes, please. That's all I ask! :D
dthomas=ddixon
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 8818
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
Location: McMinnville, Oregon

Re: Recruiting 2012

Post by dthomas=ddixon »

I don't think we've ever had a class this good this early. So I'm not really sure what there is to be worried about. Yes, USC is rolling everybody in recruiting. Which has been a long time coming, they're finally back in the top dog spotlight. It would be weird if they weren't pulling it the guys that they are.
Image
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40727
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Recruiting 2012

Post by UOducksTK1 »

I'm not going to spank you because I don't like what you say, but rather because you're wrong.

I look at star average more than the # of commits (quality over quantity).
According to scout and rivals, Oregon has the #6 and #7 average star ranking.
http://oregon.scout.com/a.z?s=128&p=9&c=14&yr=2013
http://rivals.yahoo.com/ncaa/football/r ... 13/all/all

Pretty freaking good if you ask me. Yes USC is murdering us, but that's USC. If we finish top 10 in average star rating, then that's a great year.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
Braveheart
Sophomore
Posts: 1549
Joined: Thu Jan 13, 2011 1:46 am

Re: Recruiting 2012

Post by Braveheart »

Just because the "sexy" prospects aren't there anymore doesn't mean that UO's recruiting outlook isn't good. UO isn't gonna beat USC head to head in recruiting. Now that we have that out of the way, let's look at what UO has....

1. Thomas Tyner: One of the best RB prospects in the country, with arguably the highest upside.

2. Alex Redmond: One of the top OL prospects in California, and really backed that up at the opening (put Eddie V on his butt in 1-on-1's, and was consistent with all of his reps).

3. Darren Carrington: My favorite recruit in your class. Have you seen this kids Jr tape? This guy should be Maehl-Man Ver.2.5

4. Chris Seisay: legit 6'1"+, and agile enough to play CB at a high level. Good ball-skills for a DB (if that's what he's gonna play at UO).

5. Dontre Wilson: As good of a fit for UO's offense as any back in this class. Barner Ver.2.5


I haven't really looked at Voeller's or Mundt's tape in depth, so I won't comment on them. Wogan isn't a walk-on kicker, so he has to be good...right?

What USC is doing is not the standard for anybody (including USC). UO still has time to finish their class with more quality players. Kids haven't even played their senior seasons yet. There will be plenty of kids rising/shining after their senior seasons that we don't know about or know little about. Before the summer, how many of you duck fans really knew who Chris Seisay, Darren Carrington, or Alex Redmond were? Sky isn't falling, have faith in your staff and how they recruit.
Image
User avatar
greenyellow
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 39373
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
Location: Eugene, OR

Re: Recruiting 2012

Post by greenyellow »

The way I look at is that USC has mostly filled up its class, meaning a lot of prospects will have to look elsewhere, possibly Oregon, to get a D1 scholarship. Plus, it's only mid-July, still 7 months and a full football season away from signing day.
Image
maxduck
Senior
Posts: 3763
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:37 pm

Re: Recruiting 2012

Post by maxduck »

Braveheart wrote:3. Darren Carrington: My favorite recruit in your class. Have you seen this kids Jr tape? This guy should be Maehl-Man Ver.2.5
:D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D
User avatar
Kimber45
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 498
Joined: Fri Aug 26, 2011 5:39 pm
Location: Alaska

Re: Recruiting 2012

Post by Kimber45 »

While I appreciate the importance of recruiting to program success, I don't closely follow recruiting because of the dramatic sea changes that seem to occur after every cryptic tweet by a PSA. Bryce Brown would be a perfect example of why I no longer waste emotional energy on recruiting issues.

That said, I think dt=dd is corrrect that this is our best class this early. Given the amount of returning talent, as well as red shirt kids, the Oregon cupboards are full.

Not saying that Oregon wouldn't take any elite level recruit who wants to be part of the program, but where are our glaring needs? So far this class has two stellar lineman, two rbs, several offensive skill position players, a CB and a kicker. IMO, our kicking game was one of our biggest needs and now its filled.

Had we gotten Eddie V. (or a similar DT prospect), I think all we really need is a LB.

To put our class in perspective - my perspective anyway - with a solid DT and LB commit, I think Oregon is so full of talent right now that we could shut this class down at 10 and carry the scholies to next year.

Not saying we should do that, just that the world wouldn't spin off its axis and come to an end if we did.

You can only play one player at each position at a time.

Flame away.
User avatar
JIDuck97
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 998
Joined: Fri Sep 16, 2011 8:42 am

Re: Recruiting 2012

Post by JIDuck97 »

Only thing I disagree with Braveheart on in this post is that, having watched some tape online between Wilson and Tyner, to me Tyners running style looks more like Barners and Wilsons more like LMJs. That is not a depiction on my part of who will be better at all, just rather an opinion on running style. In high school they are both excellent backs. LMJ became, in college, slippery as a wet seal in the greased hands Crisco factory workers. Right now I feel like Wilson looks pretty darn slippery (for high school backs.)

By the way, Braveheart is awesome as is our LSU friend.
Braveheart
Sophomore
Posts: 1549
Joined: Thu Jan 13, 2011 1:46 am

Re: Recruiting 2012

Post by Braveheart »

JIDuck97 wrote:Only thing I disagree with Braveheart on in this post is that, having watched some tape online between Wilson and Tyner, to me Tyners running style looks more like Barners and Wilsons more like LMJs. That is not a depiction on my part of who will be better at all, just rather an opinion on running style. In high school they are both excellent backs. LMJ became, in college, slippery as a wet seal in the greased hands Crisco factory workers. Right now I feel like Wilson looks pretty darn slippery (for high school backs.)

By the way, Braveheart is awesome as is our LSU friend.

Looking at it again, your depiction is probably more on point.
Image
uodux1212
Senior
Posts: 3965
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:44 pm
Location: Portland, OR

Re: Recruiting 2012

Post by uodux1212 »

Braveheart wrote:Just because the "sexy" prospects aren't there anymore doesn't mean that UO's recruiting outlook isn't good. UO isn't gonna beat USC head to head in recruiting. Now that we have that out of the way, let's look at what UO has....

1. Thomas Tyner: One of the best RB prospects in the country, with arguably the highest upside.

2. Alex Redmond: One of the top OL prospects in California, and really backed that up at the opening (put Eddie V on his butt in 1-on-1's, and was consistent with all of his reps).

3. Darren Carrington: My favorite recruit in your class. Have you seen this kids Jr tape? This guy should be Maehl-Man Ver.2.5

4. Chris Seisay: legit 6'1"+, and agile enough to play CB at a high level. Good ball-skills for a DB (if that's what he's gonna play at UO).

5. Dontre Wilson: As good of a fit for UO's offense as any back in this class. Barner Ver.2.5


I haven't really looked at Voeller's or Mundt's tape in depth, so I won't comment on them. Wogan isn't a walk-on kicker, so he has to be good...right?

What USC is doing is not the standard for anybody (including USC). UO still has time to finish their class with more quality players. Kids haven't even played their senior seasons yet. There will be plenty of kids rising/shining after their senior seasons that we don't know about or know little about. Before the summer, how many of you duck fans really knew who Chris Seisay, Darren Carrington, or Alex Redmond were? Sky isn't falling, have faith in your staff and how they recruit.

There you go being all rational and reasonable about things....are you familiar w message boards at all?!?
Image

"How do we go from nine to one?" - Chip Kelly

“Our expectations are to win every game we play." - CK
Braveheart
Sophomore
Posts: 1549
Joined: Thu Jan 13, 2011 1:46 am

Re: Recruiting 2012

Post by Braveheart »

uodux1212 wrote:
Braveheart wrote:Just because the "sexy" prospects aren't there anymore doesn't mean that UO's recruiting outlook isn't good. UO isn't gonna beat USC head to head in recruiting. Now that we have that out of the way, let's look at what UO has....

1. Thomas Tyner: One of the best RB prospects in the country, with arguably the highest upside.

2. Alex Redmond: One of the top OL prospects in California, and really backed that up at the opening (put Eddie V on his butt in 1-on-1's, and was consistent with all of his reps).

3. Darren Carrington: My favorite recruit in your class. Have you seen this kids Jr tape? This guy should be Maehl-Man Ver.2.5

4. Chris Seisay: legit 6'1"+, and agile enough to play CB at a high level. Good ball-skills for a DB (if that's what he's gonna play at UO).

5. Dontre Wilson: As good of a fit for UO's offense as any back in this class. Barner Ver.2.5


I haven't really looked at Voeller's or Mundt's tape in depth, so I won't comment on them. Wogan isn't a walk-on kicker, so he has to be good...right?

What USC is doing is not the standard for anybody (including USC). UO still has time to finish their class with more quality players. Kids haven't even played their senior seasons yet. There will be plenty of kids rising/shining after their senior seasons that we don't know about or know little about. Before the summer, how many of you duck fans really knew who Chris Seisay, Darren Carrington, or Alex Redmond were? Sky isn't falling, have faith in your staff and how they recruit.

There you go being all rational and reasonable about things....are you familiar w message boards at all?!?
Things are never as good as they seem, and they're never as bad as they seem either.
Image
vagusnerve
Freshman
Posts: 1383
Joined: Tue Feb 02, 2010 12:56 pm

Re: Recruiting 2012

Post by vagusnerve »

Pretty much totally agreed with everyone here.

I really like the current Duck commits. There's a ton of talent there and I know the coaches put in a lot of thought before they offered those guys so they are probably *great* fits with the team.

In the OP, I was more speaking to the second half of the class.

As I understand it, there aren't really any "top" players left with offers. It seems like they lost out on a lot of first or second option players to other schools besides USC, especially at LB. I'm definitely not crying, I agree that we could probably shut down this class right now with another player or two and be fine.

Oregon can definitely come on strong and clean up because USC is full. But will there be anything left to fill up on?
wlduck
Sophomore
Posts: 1722
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 3:19 pm

Re: Recruiting 2012

Post by wlduck »

vagusnerve wrote:Pretty much totally agreed with everyone here.

I really like the current Duck commits. There's a ton of talent there and I know the coaches put in a lot of thought before they offered those guys so they are probably *great* fits with the team.

In the OP, I was more speaking to the second half of the class.

As I understand it, there aren't really any "top" players left with offers. It seems like they lost out on a lot of first or second option players to other schools besides USC, especially at LB. I'm definitely not crying, I agree that we could probably shut down this class right now with another player or two and be fine.

Oregon can definitely come on strong and clean up because USC is full. But will there be anything left to fill up on?
Yes- considering our ability to reach nationally, there will be plenty left.
maxduck
Senior
Posts: 3763
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:37 pm

Re: Recruiting 2012

Post by maxduck »

vagusnerve wrote:Pretty much totally agreed with everyone here.

I really like the current Duck commits. There's a ton of talent there and I know the coaches put in a lot of thought before they offered those guys so they are probably *great* fits with the team.

In the OP, I was more speaking to the second half of the class.

As I understand it, there aren't really any "top" players left with offers. It seems like they lost out on a lot of first or second option players to other schools besides USC, especially at LB. I'm definitely not crying, I agree that we could probably shut down this class right now with another player or two and be fine.

Oregon can definitely come on strong and clean up because USC is full. But will there be anything left to fill up on?
A quick glance at Scout shows about a dozen uncommitted players, each ranked in the top 10 at their position, with both offers and interest in Oregon. Plus we still have an entire season of high school football for kids to display their talent.
gogreen55
Senior
Posts: 2369
Joined: Sat Apr 30, 2011 8:39 pm

Re: Recruiting 2012

Post by gogreen55 »

Keep in mind that on this date last year the following things were true...
  • Bralon Addison was committed to Texas A & M.
  • Pharaoh Brown was committed to Michigan.
  • Most people felt Arik Armstead to Oregon was a bit of a longshot.
  • Dwayne Stanford was thought to be a lock to join his good friend and teammate at Ohio State.
  • I doubt few, if any, Oregon fans had players like Terrance Daniel or Chance Allen anywhere on their radar (not big name players I know, but there will be at least a couple players like this that nobody is talking about right now that will be a part of this recruiting class).
Lots of things will change between now and signing day. New offers will go out, players that nobody is talking about right now will pop up and the Ducks may even land a player or two that are currently committed to other schools. While I would obviously prefer that our recruiting more closely resemble USC's, I don't think there is much reason to be less optimistic about this Oregon recruiting class than there was about the last recruiting class at this exact same point last year.
Post Reply