Is Herbert > Mariota
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
- DuckMastaFunk
- Five Star Recruit
- Posts: 1044
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:07 pm
Is Herbert > Mariota
Three weeks ago I would have called this blasphemous. Now, I'm pretty conflicted about the statement.
- bigsugarduck
- Five Star Recruit
- Posts: 1209
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 9:52 pm
Re: Is Herbert > Mariota
Mariotas career will never be topped... And I think his teams were more dominant. If Herbert doesn't lose another game this year then let's talk. I think Herbert is a better passer right now however.
Stewart Mandel-"From a purely aesthetic standpoint, I much prefer to watch a good spread-rushing offense over a traditional Power-I offense, and Oregon's has been the most fun by far for the past several years. It's fast, its precise, and when Chip Kelly has the right quarterback (Dixon, Masoli) at the helm, the possibility of someone ripping off a 60-yard run exists on nearly every play."
- Alan
- Senior
- Posts: 4359
- Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: Is Herbert > Mariota
Mariota is still the all time best overall. But I would very easily put Herbert in the "new era" top three. New era meaning I'm not grouping him with Dan Fouts or Chris Miller era's. O many things in football are different these days. He is certainly in my top three modern era, Marcus, Joey, and Herbert......... Marcus is number one but I don't know how to rank Joey and Herbert.
-
ducks5ever
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 936
- Joined: Tue Jan 10, 2017 12:15 pm
Re: Is Herbert > Mariota
How many games did Mariota lose in his entire career and how many has Herbert already lost?
They both have great character though
They both have great character though
-
northbeachsf
- Freshman
- Posts: 1494
- Joined: Tue Jan 13, 2009 12:54 pm
Re: Is Herbert > Mariota
I am not sure it is fair to judge by wins and losses. Marcus had several reliable receivers that could separate and a supporting run game that would gouge opponents, leaving receivers one on one and running open down the field. Right now Justin only has one reliable receiver that can separate and an average run game at best.
Marcus is probably the better athlete, but some of the throws Justin has made this year are unmatched. Those tight window throws down the field (like to Kano and Mitchell in the Cal game), I am not sure Marcus would have even thrown those balls.
Marcus is still on top, but I think Justin is starting to play himself into the discussion.
Marcus is probably the better athlete, but some of the throws Justin has made this year are unmatched. Those tight window throws down the field (like to Kano and Mitchell in the Cal game), I am not sure Marcus would have even thrown those balls.
Marcus is still on top, but I think Justin is starting to play himself into the discussion.
-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: Is Herbert > Mariota
Alan wrote:Mariota is still the all time best overall. But I would very easily put Herbert in the "new era" top three. New era meaning I'm not grouping him with Dan Fouts or Chris Miller era's. O many things in football are different these days. He is certainly in my top three modern era, Marcus, Joey, and Herbert......... Marcus is number one but I don't know how to rank Joey and Herbert.
Joey got a lot of praise for leading a lot of comebacks. The problem is, people forget he was the main reason they were in that spot to begin with.
As of today
MM8
Herbert
Joey
And if I'm being honest, I'd take a heathy Dixon and Akili over Joey as well. Akili qoild have been fun to watch if he'd had Chip. He had an arm like Herberts, and could run like Marcus. To bad he didnt have ot between the ears.
Last edited by buckmarkduck on Mon Oct 01, 2018 8:15 am, edited 1 time in total.
- Alan
- Senior
- Posts: 4359
- Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: Is Herbert > Mariota
Agreed, plus this is the first season Herbert has had a solid defensive supporting the offense, Marcus always had good defensive support.northbeachsf wrote:I am not sure it is fair to judge by wins and losses. Marcus had several reliable receivers that could separate and a supporting run game that would gouge opponents, leaving receivers one on one and running open down the field. Right now Justin only has one reliable receiver that can separate and an average run game at best.
Marcus is probably the better athlete, but some of the throws Justin has made this year are unmatched. Those tight window throws down the field (like to Kano and Mitchell in the Cal game), I am not sure Marcus would have even thrown those balls.
Marcus is still on top, but I think Justin is starting to play himself into the discussion.
- OregonFan4Life
- All-American
- Posts: 15429
- Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm
Re: Is Herbert > Mariota
Herbert has a better arm, he makes NFL throws that I’m sure has scouts drooling. However Marcus is better, Marcus was so incredibly smart and steady, ran the zone read to perfection, knew how to avoid injury, and was an amazing leader. Marcus didn’t have to make perfect throws because he knew how to confuse a defense and get guys wide open. Just like against Florida State, he had a long touchdown pass to Carrington, and sure the pass didn’t look amazing, but the way he used his eyes to fool the defense was. That’s something Herbert hasn’t gotten down yet, but if he does and can combine that skill with his arm and decent athleticism, the NFL better watch out.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Re: Is Herbert > Mariota
For now, 00's or after-
1. Mariota
2. Dixon
3. Herbert
If we're talking about best passers to put on a Ducks jersey, 00's or after
1. Adams
2. Herbert
3. Mariota or Joey
We've never had someone with Adams' deep ball, before or since.
1. Mariota
2. Dixon
3. Herbert
If we're talking about best passers to put on a Ducks jersey, 00's or after
1. Adams
2. Herbert
3. Mariota or Joey
We've never had someone with Adams' deep ball, before or since.
-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: Is Herbert > Mariota
StevensTechU wrote:For now, 00's or after-
1. Mariota
2. Dixon
3. Herbert
If we're talking about best passers to put on a Ducks jersey, 00's or after
1. Adams
2. Herbert
3. Mariota or Joey
We've never had someone with Adams' deep ball, before or since.
While Dixon had 6 good games, he also had a lot of WTF games. Herbert hasn't really had those types of problems. The games we have lost with JH, have been on the D and coaching. He really hasn't lost any games. Dixon as a Jr was a mess mentally.
-
AshlandDuck
- Three Star Recruit
- Posts: 305
- Joined: Mon Jun 18, 2018 1:51 am
Re: Is Herbert > Mariota
Akili Smith's senior year will always be a top 3 for me. He was throwing darts like Herbert is now and was great in the pocket. As pretty as Herbert's balls are, I actually think Akili's were prettier. Akili also had two great college WR in Hartley and Griffin and an NFL TE in Jed Weaver, so the passing game was more successful. I can only imagine what he would've done with Chip at the helm with that offense. Chip's one year with Dixon was amazing in his ability to take advantage of Dixon's running ability. Dixon like Akili was known as a pocket passer when they were recruited as Dixon played in a passing offense in HS. I think Akili would've been something to behold. Here's a clip to paint a picture of Akili's size and burst.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NBTj7yzz-8I
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NBTj7yzz-8I
- Phalanx
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5319
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:50 pm
Re: Is Herbert > Mariota
It's kind of a bummer how Harrington is getting knocked in later years because of his lack of success in the NFL. The guy did amazing things at Oregon. I don't think Herbert will ever approach either Mariota or Harrington for college success, and neither is he likely to have years like Dixon and Akili's, or even Vernon Adams's senior seasons. I firmly believe, however, that Justin will have a better NFL career than any of those guys. To me, he is a throwback to the Fouts and Miller era. Having two Ducks as starting QB's in the NFL is going to be awesome.
-
GoDucksIn09
- Senior
- Posts: 3086
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:15 am
Re: Is Herbert > Mariota
I think Mariota is far better, because he did not throw interceptions. He was smart with the ball. One criticism have heard with Herbert is sometimes he hangs onto the ball to long and will get sacked. That is something can not do in the pro game. The players are so fast in pro that if he dos that to much he will have a short career in pros. The successful quarterbacks in pro have a mental clock and know have to get rid of the ball before that clock goes off. Herbert needs to be aware of that. Mariota is also a far better athlete. I don't question the fact that Herbert is a better passer. Right now I would still prefer to have Mariota if a pro scout because he does not throw interceptions and can make plays with his legs. If Herbert shows awareness of the mental clock consistently and gets rid of the ball then maybe he will be better.
- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: Is Herbert > Mariota
We've never had a QB with the arm talent that Herbert has but some of you have some pretty funny responses.

-
duckfan96
- Senior
- Posts: 2717
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:58 pm
Re: Is Herbert > Mariota
Love Marcus, and as above poster said, he didn’t thow too many ints. But didn’t he fumble a bit? Herbert won’t have the wins in college but I think he will be the most successful Oregon qb in the nfl. Jmo