How many coaches should be fired?

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

Post Reply
dthomas=ddixon
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 8832
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
Location: McMinnville, Oregon

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by dthomas=ddixon »

UOducksTK1 wrote:
dthomas=ddixon wrote:I just can't push the thought out of my head that if VA is healthy we are very likely 5-1 right now. We would all be happy for the most part, Pez would still be here blaming the offense for the defensive struggles, and only the same small group of us would be unhappy with the defense.

Obviously our defense is a joke and Pellum should be let go the second the season is over but I just can't bring myself to believe that Helf and Frost are this bad. I mean, even without a QB, statistically, we still have a pretty good offense. Which is impressive.

You could also argue that we are down to our 3rd and 4th string QB. If Waller/Jonson were healthy I have to think that he would be getting the bulk of the playing time.
I don't think that's true. If we are in the 100-120 range for PPG and YPG defensively, pretty sure people would still be up in arms.
Yeah you're right, I was being a bit exaggerative.

I've had a few conversations with fans who want Helf fired but when you ask them why their response is something along the lines of, "Uh dude, our quarterbacks suck. That's on Helf!" That's who that argument is directed at.

I think it's an overreaction to want Helf and Frost fired. If Helf sticks with Prllum Ayer this year then I'll join the fire Helf bandwagon.
Image
timberduck
Two Star Recruit
Posts: 113
Joined: Sun Jan 04, 2015 6:59 pm

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by timberduck »

If we didn't have Royce we would probably be the worst team in the Pac 12. Think about that. 9 months removed from playing in the natty.

Elite programs and elite coaches have down years, but they don't implode like this. They don't get blown out by 40+ points at home. When's the last time USC, Ohio State, Alabama etc. lost by 40 points in their own stadium? Has it ever happened?

This season is a failure of coaching at some level, probably multiple levels.
User avatar
Alan
Senior
Posts: 4359
Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by Alan »

Even with being able to reach two NC games in recent years the Ducks, even with Marcus, is a long way from being in the same group as USC, OhIo St and Bama. Those schools have decades of being a elite team behind them, yea I'm channeling Joey, but it's so true.

The ducks have major problems, foremost is at QB and DB. Firing Helf and Frost, IMO, is a major over reaction and I'll give DP a couple of more games before I jump on that bandwagon.

Developing a QB does fall on the coaches, but if a 3,4 or 5 star recruit just doesn't have the "whatever" factor to make the leap from high school to major college ball it's not on the coaches. The whatever factor could be mental strength, arm development, intelligence, maturity, etc. that does not fall on the coaches.
SuperDuck
Senior
Posts: 4671
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
Location: Arizona, USA
Contact:

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by SuperDuck »

Alan wrote:Even with being able to reach two NC games in recent years the Ducks, even with Marcus, is a long way from being in the same group as USC, Ohio St and Bama. Those schools have decades of being a elite team behind them, yea I'm channeling Joey, but it's so true.
Agreed. Oregon has become a national brand, but they still don't have the history of those schools mentioned.
Alan wrote:The Ducks have major problems, foremost is at QB and DB. Firing Helf and Frost, IMO, is a major over reaction and I'll give DP a couple of more games before I jump on that bandwagon.
Exactly. Bobby Bowden used to almost consistently have a redshirt junior waiting in the wings to take over when a QB would graduate. Oregon has one, Lockie, but he's just been too inconsistent. Part of that IS on the coaches! He should have gotten more meaningful playing time last year, but I tend to think the coaches were letting Marcus pad his stats as much as possible because of the Heisman push. I get that, but it's coming back to bite them now.

The injuries to Adams and Jonsen have compounded the situation at QB to the point where the offense doesn't even resemble the Oregon offense we've all come to know and love. Right now the talent and game experience simply isn't there. If VA doesn't make it back soon, Helfrich may be better off just playing Lockie the rest of the way so he can get some much needed experience for next season. He'll be back. VA won't.
Alan wrote:Developing a QB does fall on the coaches, but if a 3,4 or 5 star recruit just doesn't have the "whatever" factor to make the leap from high school to major college ball it's not on the coaches. The whatever factor could be mental strength, arm development, intelligence, maturity, etc. that does not fall on the coaches.
That's a fact. I recall reading somewhere that apx 50% of all 5 star players are busts or don't live up to expectations. Coaches can break down film until the cows come home and even be excited and confident that they've brought in some great players, but there's just no way to tell how a player is going to perform until you actually see them in practice every day and who takes advantage of their opportunities.

Regarding Pellum, from what I've read, he's simplified the defense a LOT because of all the freshman. That, plus the addition of Charles Nelson on defense showed against WSU. One thing the young players aren't doing, though, is actually tackling! That's maddening to watch again and again! Players lead with their shoulders and go for the big hits, but they're not wrapping up. Remember how Ifo Expre-Olomu wrapped people up in the open field? If he got his hands on a dude that guy was going down 80% of the time. He didn't just "launch" himself at people, he tackled them! We need to see more of that. Back to the basics!

From what I understand, Reggie Daniels and Chris Seisay were both out against WSU. Seisay is out indefinitely. I haven't heard anything else about Daniels. Tyree Robinson has been playing corner, too. Umadi, Springs and Ihenacho are playing hard and are going to get a lot better, but they're so young right now that it's difficult, and even a bit unrealistic, to expect them to step on the field and be all world right out of the gate. Once again, they're going to get better. This will payoff in a BIG way next year!

I don't think the Ducks are nearly as bad as they're being portrayed. As has been mentioned by several others, we could easily be 5-1 right now. The Utah game was a fluke. Yes, they beat us fair and square, but that was one of those "on any given Saturday" games. Utah would have destroyed a lot of good teams that day. We just happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time and didn't execute when it counted in all areas of the game, offense, defense and special teams.

We have 6 tough games left. If we could find a way to go at least 4-2, that would put us at 7-5 and a Bowl win would put us at 8-5. That's respectable, considering all the adversity they've faced this season.

I'd expect a few positions to be wide open next spring, though. In the meantime...

...Go Ducks!!! 8-) 8-) 8-)
John 3:36
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by buckmarkduck »

It's one thing to miss on a qb, it's another thing entirely to miss this badley. Three of our 4 QBs this year, wouldn't even start at most D II schools. Ewu had 3 QBs last season better than our 3 backups. How does something like that happen?
SuperDuck
Senior
Posts: 4671
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
Location: Arizona, USA
Contact:

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by SuperDuck »

buckmarkduck wrote:It's one thing to miss on a qb, it's another thing entirely to miss this badly. Three of our 4 QBs this year, wouldn't even start at most D II schools. Ewu had 3 QBs last season better than our 3 backups. How does something like that happen?
Lockie isn't great, but I wouldn't label him a bust just yet because he simply hasn't had enough game reps to make an educated judgment. VA is hurt. Mahalak is a mystery. He's running the scout team because he was deemed to not be "operationally ready". Jonsen is hurt and Alie is a walk-on. I'd have to believe that Jonsen would have seen the field by now if not for the injury.

Stuff happens. It sucks, but it does.
John 3:36
User avatar
Alan
Senior
Posts: 4359
Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by Alan »

buckmarkduck wrote:It's one thing to miss on a qb, it's another thing entirely to miss this badley. Three of our 4 QBs this year, wouldn't even start at most D II schools. Ewu had 3 QBs last season better than our 3 backups. How does something like that happen?
Developing a QB does fall on the coaches, but if a 3,4 or 5 star recruit just doesn't have the "whatever" factor to make the leap from high school to major college ball it's not on the coaches. The whatever factor could be mental strength, arm development, intelligence, maturity, etc. that does not fall on the coaches.
. And what super duck said so much better than I could...... It sucks, but it's not over.
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by buckmarkduck »

But recruiting is on the coach. Look I want to be positive about the QBs, but look at the QBs recruited the last 5 years. One was a home run, the other that year plays at UA now, and looks like Lockie except he can run. Jake Rod was well known in HS for being hot and cold, and throwing int. that never changed at UO. Lockie was a throwin that year, and he lived up to what everyone thought. A guy who should be a 3-4th string not to be counted on. Morgan might be the biggest miss, given the facts we easily could have had Manny Wilkons who's at ASU. Then last year Frost, knowing the situation, chose to ignore the easy gets like White (at asu) and chased only the top guys. In reality he should have told everyone, hey we have no qb and we need 2-3 QBs in this class. He got very lucky to land Travis, who I think will be good, but he should have taken 1-2 more guys.

And yes we've seen more than enough of Lockie to know he will never amount to an actual pac 12 qb. Anyone arguing otherwise, is lying to themselves.
wepto
Five Star Recruit
Posts: 1074
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 11:07 pm

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by wepto »

buckmarkduck wrote:But recruiting is on the coach. Look I want to be positive about the QBs, but look at the QBs recruited the last 5 years. One was a home run, the other that year plays at UA now, and looks like Lockie except he can run. Jake Rod was well known in HS for being hot and cold, and throwing int. that never changed at UO. Lockie was a throwin that year, and he lived up to what everyone thought. A guy who should be a 3-4th string not to be counted on. Morgan might be the biggest miss, given the facts we easily could have had Manny Wilkons who's at ASU. Then last year Frost, knowing the situation, chose to ignore the easy gets like White (at asu) and chased only the top guys. In reality he should have told everyone, hey we have no qb and we need 2-3 QBs in this class. He got very lucky to land Travis, who I think will be good, but he should have taken 1-2 more guys.

And yes we've seen more than enough of Lockie to know he will never amount to an actual pac 12 qb. Anyone arguing otherwise, is lying to themselves.
Hindsight bias.

Teams recruit an average of 1 QB a year. 5* prospects bust about half the time. 4* and 3* prospects bust more than that. Then there are injuries. It's not hard math--every single program will have years where they have a subpar QB.
SuperDuck
Senior
Posts: 4671
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
Location: Arizona, USA
Contact:

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by SuperDuck »

wepto wrote:
buckmarkduck wrote:But recruiting is on the coach. Look I want to be positive about the QBs, but look at the QBs recruited the last 5 years. One was a home run, the other that year plays at UA now, and looks like Lockie except he can run. Jake Rod was well known in HS for being hot and cold, and throwing int. that never changed at UO. Lockie was a throwin that year, and he lived up to what everyone thought. A guy who should be a 3-4th string not to be counted on. Morgan might be the biggest miss, given the facts we easily could have had Manny Wilkons who's at ASU. Then last year Frost, knowing the situation, chose to ignore the easy gets like White (at asu) and chased only the top guys. In reality he should have told everyone, hey we have no qb and we need 2-3 QBs in this class. He got very lucky to land Travis, who I think will be good, but he should have taken 1-2 more guys.

And yes we've seen more than enough of Lockie to know he will never amount to an actual pac 12 qb. Anyone arguing otherwise, is lying to themselves.
Hindsight bias.

Teams recruit an average of 1 QB a year. 5* prospects bust about half the time. 4* and 3* prospects bust more than that. Then there are injuries. It's not hard math--every single program will have years where they have a subpar QB.
+1

Sad, but true. Frost DID go after Brady White and offered him, but White had already been to ASU twice on unofficial visits and felt at home.

http://arizonastate.247sports.com/Artic ... e-28445403

To think that the staff would just "settle" for lower ranked recruits because they don't think they have a shot at the higher ranked guys is nuts. They should absolutely have their hat in the ring for the best guys EVERY year! Oregon has a lot to offer and some guys will want to come here. Of course, some won't, too, but that doesn't necessarily close the door on other kids. They're not dumb, they understand that schools have a pecking order, that there are only so many slots available and they want to get the best players in those slots they possibly can.

I just don't get the rationale of some posters lately. They're totally posting emotionally instead of thinking of things logically. I won't be around for awhile after tomorrow if we lose tonight. Prozac for everybody!!! Sheesh.
John 3:36
cesame
Two Star Recruit
Posts: 102
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 5:47 pm

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by cesame »

Why is Morgan Mahalak considered a miss? He's a redshirt freshman. Other than Mariota, when was the last time that young of a QB was the #1 guy for the Ducks? Let's take a look

Thomas was a redshirt sophomore
Masoli was a junior
Dixon wasn't the man until his SENIOR year
Kellen Clemens redshirt sophomore (split some reps with Fife that year)
JOEY HEISMAN wasn't the man until his JR year

Morgan Mahalak is still very much in play. He's not even close to being a finished product, and as a redshirt FRESHMAN, don't even begin to start counting him out. Not every player comes in right away and shines like Mariota. He's the exception, not the rule.
mdm0302
Freshman
Posts: 1349
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:38 pm
Location: Eugene O

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by mdm0302 »

cesame wrote:Why is Morgan Mahalak considered a miss? He's a redshirt freshman. Other than Mariota, when was the last time that young of a QB was the #1 guy for the Ducks? Let's take a look

Thomas was a redshirt sophomore
Masoli was a junior
Dixon wasn't the man until his SENIOR year
Kellen Clemens redshirt sophomore (split some reps with Fife that year)
JOEY HEISMAN wasn't the man until his JR year

Morgan Mahalak is still very much in play. He's not even close to being a finished product, and as a redshirt FRESHMAN, don't even begin to start counting him out. Not every player comes in right away and shines like Mariota. He's the exception, not the rule.
agreed!
duckfan22
Senior
Posts: 2698
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:48 pm

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by duckfan22 »

I won't be around for awhile after tomorrow if we lose tonight. Prozac for everybody!!! Sheesh.

Good God if we lose tonight i can only imagine the melt down in here. Most likely to hot to even
touch the keyboard. Of course i will be to upset to even look.. will wait a few days to let things cool off..
But i think the ducks beat the puppies again...Keeping positive
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by buckmarkduck »

timberduck wrote:If we didn't have Royce we would probably be the worst team in the Pac 12. Think about that. 9 months removed from playing in the natty.

Elite programs and elite coaches have down years, but they don't implode like this. They don't get blown out by 40+ points at home. When's the last time USC, Ohio State, Alabama etc. lost by 40 points in their own stadium? Has it ever happened?

This season is a failure of coaching at some level, probably multiple levels.

Have you seen oregon state?
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by buckmarkduck »

cesame wrote:Why is Morgan Mahalak considered a miss? He's a redshirt freshman. Other than Mariota, when was the last time that young of a QB was the #1 guy for the Ducks? Let's take a look

Thomas was a redshirt sophomore
Masoli was a junior
Dixon wasn't the man until his SENIOR year
Kellen Clemens redshirt sophomore (split some reps with Fife that year)
JOEY HEISMAN wasn't the man until his JR year

Morgan Mahalak is still very much in play. He's not even close to being a finished product, and as a redshirt FRESHMAN, don't even begin to start counting him out. Not every player comes in right away and shines like Mariota. He's the exception, not the rule.
Joey was the man midway through his So year, when Aj went out vs Arizona. Dixon started out fine then Bellotti ruined him, by screwing with his confidence. I can tell you, Morgan is in the dog house, maybe he turns it around but believe me the coaches during the summer, encouraged him to look elsewhere.

I don't understand how none of this is the coaches fault? I don't think anyone is saying to fire them because of it, but the blame belongs squarely on the coaches. It's pretty simple, now they need to fix it. UO hasn't had a bad #1 (not backups forced in due to injuries) qb in 25 years. I've said it before, even last year, frost is a fine OC, but I don't think he's a very good qb coach. They need to hire a qb guru. Not every OC in America is a qb coach.
Post Reply