Alan wrote:Even with being able to reach two NC games in recent years the Ducks, even with Marcus, is a long way from being in the same group as USC, Ohio St and Bama. Those schools have decades of being a elite team behind them, yea I'm channeling Joey, but it's so true.
Agreed. Oregon has become a national brand, but they still don't have the history of those schools mentioned.
Alan wrote:The Ducks have major problems, foremost is at QB and DB. Firing Helf and Frost, IMO, is a major over reaction and I'll give DP a couple of more games before I jump on that bandwagon.
Exactly. Bobby Bowden used to almost consistently have a redshirt junior waiting in the wings to take over when a QB would graduate. Oregon has one, Lockie, but he's just been too inconsistent. Part of that
IS on the coaches! He should have gotten more meaningful playing time last year, but I tend to think the coaches were letting Marcus pad his stats as much as possible because of the Heisman push. I get that, but it's coming back to bite them now.
The injuries to Adams and Jonsen have compounded the situation at QB to the point where the offense doesn't even resemble the Oregon offense we've all come to know and love. Right now the talent and game experience simply isn't there. If VA doesn't make it back soon, Helfrich may be better off just playing Lockie the rest of the way so he can get some much needed experience for next season. He'll be back. VA won't.
Alan wrote:Developing a QB does fall on the coaches, but if a 3,4 or 5 star recruit just doesn't have the "whatever" factor to make the leap from high school to major college ball it's not on the coaches. The whatever factor could be mental strength, arm development, intelligence, maturity, etc. that does not fall on the coaches.
That's a fact. I recall reading somewhere that apx 50% of all 5 star players are busts or don't live up to expectations. Coaches can break down film until the cows come home and even be excited and confident that they've brought in some great players, but there's just no way to tell how a player is going to perform until you actually see them in practice every day and who takes advantage of their opportunities.
Regarding Pellum, from what I've read, he's simplified the defense a
LOT because of all the freshman. That, plus the addition of Charles Nelson on defense showed against WSU. One thing the young players aren't doing, though, is actually
tackling! That's maddening to watch again and again! Players lead with their shoulders and go for the big hits, but they're not wrapping up. Remember how Ifo Expre-Olomu wrapped people up in the open field? If he got his hands on a dude that guy was going down 80% of the time. He didn't just "launch" himself at people, he tackled them! We need to see more of that. Back to the basics!
From what I understand, Reggie Daniels and Chris Seisay were both out against WSU. Seisay is out indefinitely. I haven't heard anything else about Daniels. Tyree Robinson has been playing corner, too. Umadi, Springs and Ihenacho are playing hard and are going to get a lot better, but they're so young right now that it's difficult, and even a bit unrealistic, to expect them to step on the field and be all world right out of the gate. Once again, they're going to get better. This will payoff in a BIG way next year!
I don't think the Ducks are nearly as bad as they're being portrayed. As has been mentioned by several others, we could easily be 5-1 right now. The Utah game was a fluke. Yes, they beat us fair and square, but that was one of those "on any given Saturday" games. Utah would have destroyed a lot of good teams that day. We just happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time and didn't execute when it counted in all areas of the game, offense, defense and special teams.
We have 6 tough games left. If we could find a way to go at least 4-2, that would put us at 7-5 and a Bowl win would put us at 8-5. That's respectable, considering all the adversity they've faced this season.
I'd expect a few positions to be wide open next spring, though. In the meantime...
...Go Ducks!!!
