Another way of looking at it is what is the benefit of continuing to start Prukop? Because you think we can still goto the play-off?
If Prukop gives us the best chance to win the Pac-12 championship, then we should play him. If Herbert gives us the best chance, then we should play him.
Meritocracy 100 percent, imo. I'd only back burner the meritocracy once we're mathematically out of the running for the Pac-12 title.
It's easy for us to guess whether we think Herbert would be better than Prukop, but honestly... that would be a tall order. I mean, who knows? But as mad as people might be over losing on the road to Nebraska, the fact remains that Prukop is actually pretty good. Had Nelson made that last catch -- or had the refs not robbed Prukop of the chance to win in overtime -- then we'd probably be talking about how he showed grit and leadership and stepped up when it mattered.
Put Herbert (who we still haven't seen take a meaningful snap) in those situations against Nebraska. Honestly believe a freshman QB who doesn't know the entire playbook would have fared better? Or even the same?
If the coaches are starting Prukop, then that means Herbert just isn't ready yet, and they believe Prukop gives us a better chance to win.
Colorado is the most improved team in the Pac-12, and WSU usually gives us fits. We can't afford to stray from the meritocracy.