After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

oregontrack
All Pac-12
Posts: 5118
Joined: Thu Jan 14, 2010 6:23 pm

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by oregontrack »

DAT_man_again wrote:Okay, I don't want this to sound like I'm throwing in the towel on this season, because I'm totally not. I still think we will contend for a PAC 12 title. However, this Saturday we are going to start 5 freshman on the offensive line.

whoa whoa whoa. is this true? is hunt suspended or something?
ImageImageImageImageImage
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6490
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by pezsez1 »

The OP isn't saying we should "play for next year." He's saying he thinks Herbert gives us the same chances of winning, so why not play him.

I do disagree though. I think Prukop gives us BETTER chances to win, which is why he is starting. I also think we'll beat Stanford and UW at home. Sucks we lost at Nebraska, but this team will keep getting better, and Autzen gives us a good lift. I want our best players on the field when we play in those crucial games.

Win 'em both, and we have a great shot at the Pac-12 title.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
QuackAttack92
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 328
Joined: Sun Sep 18, 2016 9:01 pm

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by QuackAttack92 »

DAT_man_again wrote:
QuackAttack92 wrote:I really wish this thread was sarcastic but the sad thing is is that it isnt...this isn't the NFL...there's no playing for a draft pick in college football...put the winners into the games
This comment is so dumb that I am now confused.
well then its fitting for this topic
"F***** score points. What's your plan?"- Chipper
User avatar
DAT_man_again
Sophomore
Posts: 1569
Joined: Wed Aug 08, 2012 7:26 pm

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by DAT_man_again »

oregontrack wrote:
DAT_man_again wrote:Okay, I don't want this to sound like I'm throwing in the towel on this season, because I'm totally not. I still think we will contend for a PAC 12 title. However, this Saturday we are going to start 5 freshman on the offensive line.

whoa whoa whoa. is this true? is hunt suspended or something?
I thought I saw Mosely say somewhere that we would be starting 5 freshman, so I assumed that meant Hunt wasn't starting.
"You know we the big brother." - Cliff Harris


"Y'all know what time it is." -Damian Lillard
User avatar
DAT_man_again
Sophomore
Posts: 1569
Joined: Wed Aug 08, 2012 7:26 pm

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by DAT_man_again »

pezsez1 wrote:The OP isn't saying we should "play for next year." He's saying he thinks Herbert gives us the same chances of winning, so why not play him.

I do disagree though. I think Prukop gives us BETTER chances to win, which is why he is starting. I also think we'll beat Stanford and UW at home. Sucks we lost at Nebraska, but this team will keep getting better, and Autzen gives us a good lift. I want our best players on the field when we play in those crucial games.

Win 'em both, and we have a great shot at the Pac-12 title.
That's exactly what I'm saying. How many people are going to comment and say that I said we are playing for next year before they realize that I meant we have a chance to be a top five team next year while still being pretty good this year?
"You know we the big brother." - Cliff Harris


"Y'all know what time it is." -Damian Lillard
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by Duck07 »

Considering that the coaches and players basically all said that Herbert is the best passer, he just needs more time in the playbook would seem to tell me that at some point soon he should take over the job.

Prukops ceiling is Masoli. I'd rather give the young guy the reps now. This OL is going to be pretty good by years end too.
Image
User avatar
Phalanx
All Pac-12
Posts: 5347
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:50 pm

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by Phalanx »

Duck07 wrote:Considering that the coaches and players basically all said that Herbert is the best passer, he just needs more time in the playbook would seem to tell me that at some point soon he should take over the job.

Prukops ceiling is Masoli. I'd rather give the young guy the reps now. This OL is going to be pretty good by years end too.
Exactly what I was thinking. Carrington and others actually said Herbert was a better passer, and certainly, there is room for improvement in that department, judging from Saturday's game.

I'm not sure why people are getting offended by the question: It seems totally legitimate to ask it, even if the answer is no. Playing the younger guy who will be here next here does have tangible advantages, and it certainly is not without precedent (See also: Darron Thomas, Marcus Mariota). I have no opinion about who is better, never having seen Herbert play, but I think it would be nice to get him some snaps in games at least.
QuackAttack92
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 328
Joined: Sun Sep 18, 2016 9:01 pm

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by QuackAttack92 »

Anyone can look good in August...playing Pac-12 opponents in a big stadium is another ballgame. IMO this ship has sailed...If we wanted to get Herbert ready he should have been named the starter from the get-go to break him in against UCD and UVA.

Either way, this is a moot point because Helfrich's seat is getting hotter and he's not about to take a risk like that, at least not unless UO loses several more games
"F***** score points. What's your plan?"- Chipper
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by Duck07 »

QuackAttack92 wrote:Anyone can look good in August...playing Pac-12 opponents in a big stadium is another ballgame. IMO this ship has sailed...If we wanted to get Herbert ready he should have been named the starter from the get-go to break him in against UCD and UVA.

Either way, this is a moot point because Helfrich's seat is getting hotter and he's not about to take a risk like that, at least not unless UO loses several more games
The ship hasn't sailed by any means and playing Herbert would actually give him a built in excuse because he's deciding to go young this year for the benefit of future years. 7-5 with a FR QB and OL is palpable. Prukop and experience just went out the window with a road loss.

Another way of looking at it is what is the benefit of continuing to start Prukop? Because you think we can still goto the play-off?
Image
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6490
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by pezsez1 »

Another way of looking at it is what is the benefit of continuing to start Prukop? Because you think we can still goto the play-off?
If Prukop gives us the best chance to win the Pac-12 championship, then we should play him. If Herbert gives us the best chance, then we should play him.

Meritocracy 100 percent, imo. I'd only back burner the meritocracy once we're mathematically out of the running for the Pac-12 title.

It's easy for us to guess whether we think Herbert would be better than Prukop, but honestly... that would be a tall order. I mean, who knows? But as mad as people might be over losing on the road to Nebraska, the fact remains that Prukop is actually pretty good. Had Nelson made that last catch -- or had the refs not robbed Prukop of the chance to win in overtime -- then we'd probably be talking about how he showed grit and leadership and stepped up when it mattered.

Put Herbert (who we still haven't seen take a meaningful snap) in those situations against Nebraska. Honestly believe a freshman QB who doesn't know the entire playbook would have fared better? Or even the same?

If the coaches are starting Prukop, then that means Herbert just isn't ready yet, and they believe Prukop gives us a better chance to win.

Colorado is the most improved team in the Pac-12, and WSU usually gives us fits. We can't afford to stray from the meritocracy.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
QuackAttack92
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 328
Joined: Sun Sep 18, 2016 9:01 pm

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by QuackAttack92 »

One thing that never ceases to amaze me whether its college or pro fans is how popular the backup QB becomes
"F***** score points. What's your plan?"- Chipper
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by Duck07 »

Well Pez, continuing to play Devil's advocate, how close would the two need to be in order for long term benefit come into play? 55:45? 51:49?

I don't see this team as capable of winning the North right now but I agree with your premise of the P12 being in reach because that's how I see Helfrich viewing it. That said, he is going to have another blunder on his hands if Herbert doesn't play another snap this season. Kind of like how we missed out on an extra year of Dennis Dixon in this offense for meaningless snaps at Oklahoma.
Image
Cedar Tree
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 379
Joined: Sat Sep 11, 2010 9:15 pm

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by Cedar Tree »

A few thoughts on this:

- The coaches will start whoever they feel gives them the best chance to win (as they should), and obviously that's Dakota. I think he's done fine so far, and he's hardly the reason the Ducks lost.

- What kind of message would that send to the team? 'Well guys, even though Dakota is playing better in practice, we're starting Herbert so he can be more prepared for next year.' ...Don't think you're gonna get many positive reactions from that. :x

- It's rare for a starting Oregon QB to stay healthy all season. I'd say there's a 90% chance (especially with 5 freshmen on the O Line) that Prukop gets injured at some point, and then it'll likely be Herbert's time to shine (hopefully). :)

- There's an old adage that says the backup QB is the most popular guy in town. I think this is being proven true once again :lol:
QuackAttack92
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 328
Joined: Sun Sep 18, 2016 9:01 pm

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by QuackAttack92 »

Cedar Tree wrote:A few thoughts on this:

- The coaches will start whoever they feel gives them the best chance to win (as they should), and obviously that's Dakota. I think he's done fine so far, and he's hardly the reason the Ducks lost.

- What kind of message would that send to the team? 'Well guys, even though Dakota is playing better in practice, we're starting Herbert so he can be more prepared for next year.' ...Don't think you're gonna get many positive reactions from that. :x

- It's rare for a starting Oregon QB to stay healthy all season. I'd say there's a 90% chance (especially with 5 freshmen on the O Line) that Prukop gets injured at some point, and then it'll likely be Herbert's time to shine (hopefully). :)

- There's an old adage that says the backup QB is the most popular guy in town. I think this is being proven true once again :lol:
Absolutely right on...Prukop is a tough sonofabitch to carry the mail...he doesnt have an off the charts skill set like Mariota or Adams, but he's done fine so far
"F***** score points. What's your plan?"- Chipper
User avatar
StevensTechU
All Pac-12
Posts: 7116
Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
Location: Hoboken, NJ

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by StevensTechU »

QuackAttack92 wrote:
Absolutely right on...Prukop is a tough sonofabitch to carry the mail...he doesnt have an off the charts skill set like Mariota or Adams, but he's done fine so far
I was probably my most obnoxious of the whole game at Memorial Stadium when Dakota trucked that safety.
Post Reply