bigsugarduck wrote:Mariotas career will never be topped... And I think his teams were more dominant. If Herbert doesn't lose another game this year then let's talk. I think Herbert is a better passer right now however.
But that's not Herbert's fault. You gotta ask the question if you took the teams Mariota had and put Herbert on them, how would he do?
It'd be close. With that being said, you can't take Mariota's success from him and what he did was really special. So until like you guys said, Herbert brings home a Heisman or gets us to the BCS playoffs, Mariota will always have the edge.
duckfan96 wrote:Love Marcus, and as above poster said, he didn’t thow too many ints. But didn’t he fumble a bit? Herbert won’t have the wins in college but I think he will be the most successful Oregon qb in the nfl. Jmo
Dan Fouts and Norm Van Brocklin are in Canton. I get that people want to talk about all the recent stuff but those two were considered among the best during their era and Fouts style of play would only have been enhanced by modern rule changes.
duckfan96 wrote:Love Marcus, and as above poster said, he didn’t thow too many ints. But didn’t he fumble a bit? Herbert won’t have the wins in college but I think he will be the most successful Oregon qb in the nfl. Jmo
Dan Fouts and Norm Van Brocklin are in Canton. I get that people want to talk about all the recent stuff but those two were considered among the best during their era and Fouts style of play would only have been enhanced by modern rule changes.
I got to see Fouts play at Oregon. Herbert is in his mold only more mobil. Who ever drafts
Herbert is going to use his skills throwing the ball and he will be very good..
duckfan96 wrote:Love Marcus, and as above poster said, he didn’t thow too many ints. But didn’t he fumble a bit? Herbert won’t have the wins in college but I think he will be the most successful Oregon qb in the nfl. Jmo
Dan Fouts and Norm Van Brocklin are in Canton. I get that people want to talk about all the recent stuff but those two were considered among the best during their era and Fouts style of play would only have been enhanced by modern rule changes.
I got to see Fouts play at Oregon. Herbert is in his mold only more mobil. Who ever drafts
Herbert is going to use his skills throwing the ball and he will be very good..
It's impossible to compare, since even though they only had a one season gap between the two of them there are so many variables.
* Marcus played in the golden age of the Blur offense. He was able to get some of the looks he got because of the potency of the running game out of that offense, and his own threat as a runner.
* Herbert definitely has more arm talent. But Marcus' strength wasn't his rocket arm and you could make an argument that guys like Clemens and Akili had better arms, but a lot of QB play is about who runs the offense better.
* I don't know if there's a single skill player on the 2018 Ducks who would start on the 2014 Ducks. Maybe Dillon Mitchell, but even then he would be behind Carrington, Allen, Stanford, Nelson.
Herbert may be a perfect NFL prospect, but Marcus has a Heisman trophy to go along with a Fiesta and Rose Bowl win. Maybe let's revisit this conversation after the end of the season.
duckfan96 wrote:Love Marcus, and as above poster said, he didn’t thow too many ints. But didn’t he fumble a bit? Herbert won’t have the wins in college but I think he will be the most successful Oregon qb in the nfl. Jmo
Dan Fouts and Norm Van Brocklin are in Canton. I get that people want to talk about all the recent stuff but those two were considered among the best during their era and Fouts style of play would only have been enhanced by modern rule changes.
I got to see Fouts play at Oregon. Herbert is in his mold only more mobil. Who ever drafts
Herbert is going to use his skills throwing the ball and he will be very good..
duckfan96 wrote:Love Marcus, and as above poster said, he didn’t thow too many ints. But didn’t he fumble a bit? Herbert won’t have the wins in college but I think he will be the most successful Oregon qb in the nfl. Jmo
Dan Fouts and Norm Van Brocklin are in Canton. I get that people want to talk about all the recent stuff but those two were considered among the best during their era and Fouts style of play would only have been enhanced by modern rule changes.
I got to see Fouts play at Oregon. Herbert is in his mold only more mobil. Who ever drafts
Herbert is going to use his skills throwing the ball and he will be very good..
Ha Ha .... what an old guy!
Ha. I still remember his first play as a Duck. Season opener against Cal in the old Multnomah Stadium, backed up against the goal line and Fouts came in for an injured Tom Blanchard. Obvious hand off, right? Nope, the pass was just off the fingertips of a streaking WR (Bob Newland?) at about the 50. Later that year Blanchard and Fouts combined to score three touchdowns in the final 4 minutes to defeat UCLA and their Heisman Trophy QB. Dan was a special player and a good person.
maxduck wrote:Ha. I still remember his first play as a Duck. Season opener against Cal in the old Multnomah Stadium, backed up against the goal line and Fouts came in for an injured Tom Blanchard. Obvious hand off, right? Nope, the pass was just off the fingertips of a streaking WR (Bob Newland?) at about the 50. Later that year Blanchard and Fouts combined to score three touchdowns in the final 4 minutes to defeat UCLA and their Heisman Trophy QB. Dan was a special player and a good person.
It was either him or Leland Glass, Ducks won the game, 31-24.
GoDucksIn09 wrote:I think Mariota is far better, because he did not throw interceptions. He was smart with the ball. One criticism have heard with Herbert is sometimes he hangs onto the ball to long and will get sacked. That is something can not do in the pro game. The players are so fast in pro that if he dos that to much he will have a short career in pros. The successful quarterbacks in pro have a mental clock and know have to get rid of the ball before that clock goes off. Herbert needs to be aware of that. Mariota is also a far better athlete. I don't question the fact that Herbert is a better passer. Right now I would still prefer to have Mariota if a pro scout because he does not throw interceptions and can make plays with his legs. If Herbert shows awareness of the mental clock consistently and gets rid of the ball then maybe he will be better.
I mean Joe Flacco gets sacked or throws picks pretty much as a career so it is possible to do that in the NFL...
Duck07 wrote:We've never had a QB with the arm talent that Herbert has but some of you have some pretty funny responses.
It's debatable with Akili. His raw arm strength might not be on par, but he could sling it and what separated his arm talent from Herbert is the rpm he would put on his throws. His balls are easier to catch, better in the wind, and what I would call prettier. Herbert can spin it pretty well too, it's not a knock on him, it's just Akili was one of the best ever prospects in terms of rpm. They noted it leading up to the draft.
As others have mentioned, the roster during Mariota's college career was more talented top to bottom. This is especially true for the running game. Mariota's success was in no small part a byproduct of teams fearing Barner, DAT, Byron Marshall, and Royce. Given an elite running game, I think Herbert very well could have a career greater than Mariota's.