Is there time for PAC 12 to change the mind?

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6482
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Is there time for PAC 12 to change the mind?

Post by pezsez1 »

Again, shudowns aren't going to help. You can't make decisions based on the chance of a vaccine, which is another discussion all together.
Shutdowns do help -- everywhere else but here, where our leaders are too incompetent to follow the blueprint of most of the rest of the world. The shutdowns should have been more helpful here, but our federal leaders (and many state governors) frittered away our sacrifices. That pisses me off greatly.

And yes, we can make decisions based on the promising info we've seen about vaccines. We have three or four vaccines in stage 3 trials and, so far, the results are incredibly promising. It's worth using restraint for a few more months if that means saving tens of thousands of lives.

Now, if we get to December and learn that all of these vaccines are failures? Then it's time to plan on proceeding without vaccine help... and hopefully, by then, we have federal leaders who can think a bit bigger about adapting to our new reality. The rest of the world is doing so much better than we are and it blows my mind that so many Americans are willing to settle for doing nothing.

Kind of related, but earlier OregonFanforLife was talking about how privileged it is to just say "shut it all down" and nothing else. It's just as privileged to expect everyone vulnerable to lock themselves in their rooms and stop working, stop caring for kids and grandkids, stop going on vacation, etc. Our economy isn't set up for older people (and especially people with health issues) to simply stop working, stay home, or rehome their children/dependents. Don't take this the wrong way, but we don't have nearly enough socialism in our capitalism for that to be a viable solution.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
User avatar
dd10snoop28
All Pac-12
Posts: 5046
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 12:06 am
GM: New Jersey Nets GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Is there time for PAC 12 to change the mind?

Post by dd10snoop28 »

pezsez1 wrote:
Again, shudowns aren't going to help. You can't make decisions based on the chance of a vaccine, which is another discussion all together.
Shutdowns do help -- everywhere else but here, where our leaders are too incompetent to follow the blueprint of most of the rest of the world. The shutdowns should have been more helpful here, but our federal leaders (and many state governors) frittered away our sacrifices. That pisses me off greatly.

And yes, we can make decisions based on the promising info we've seen about vaccines. We have three or four vaccines in stage 3 trials and, so far, the results are incredibly promising. It's worth using restraint for a few more months if that means saving tens of thousands of lives.

Now, if we get to December and learn that all of these vaccines are failures? Then it's time to plan on proceeding without vaccine help... and hopefully, by then, we have federal leaders who can think a bit bigger about adapting to our new reality. The rest of the world is doing so much better than we are and it blows my mind that so many Americans are willing to settle for doing nothing.

Kind of related, but earlier OregonFanforLife was talking about how privileged it is to just say "shut it all down" and nothing else. It's just as privileged to expect everyone vulnerable to lock themselves in their rooms and stop working, stop caring for kids and grandkids, stop going on vacation, etc. Our economy isn't set up for older people (and especially people with health issues) to simply stop working, stay home, or rehome their children/dependents. Don't take this the wrong way, but we don't have nearly enough socialism in our capitalism for that to be a viable solution.
Disagree on your first few points. It's poor planning to place your hope in a vaccine that is being rushed through trials. People's livelihoods can't wait a few more months to finally start planning for the inevitable. Shutdowns only help to prolong the suffering of communities that are living off of crumbs at this point because there are no jobs for them.

"It's just as privileged to expect everyone vulnerable to lock themselves in their rooms and stop working, stop caring for kids and grandkids, stop going on vacation, etc. Our economy isn't set up for older people (and especially people with health issues) to simply stop working, stay home, or rehome their children/dependents."

I didn't say anything about locking the elderly in their houses. It is the responsible thing to care for the elderly/health issues and to keep them out of society for safety purposes. Obviously, I'm against any sort of requirement from the government to enforce this, but it's just common sense. What is not common sense is causing damage/hurt to the rest of society by shutting down cities.

Short rant:
I'm all for socialism, if that means taking care of the poor/downcast. However, history has shown that government entities are (1) ill equipped with taking care of other people - governments are usually one of the worst-run organizations in America. Not a good idea to have them run social programs (2) governments have motives that are not for the ultimate good of the poor/downcast, but are heavily influenced by the temptation to retain power.

Our political system was designed with the concept that people were "good" and that the good people would take care of the lonely/downcast. See all of the amazing charities that were set up by people with amazing drive/ambition to take care of the poor/hurt. That is so much better of a system because (1) those organizations are run well because they have expertise in the area that they are serving (2) motivations are pure.

Lastly, people are less inclined to show compassion to others when they themselves are in a state of crisis.
Image
User avatar
Quietduck
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 623
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:43 pm

Re: Is there time for PAC 12 to change the mind?

Post by Quietduck »

It a financial fact that the larger the organization the less efficient it is in distributing support in any format. The giant aid societies eat up over 90% of the contributions before distribution. The government is even worse just check social security or medicare. The only effective way to support anyone in need is to do it at the lowest possible level. States would be better than Federal. Counties would be better than states. Cities.... The best support system to distribute care is family and friends. Local charities would be next best. 1 million dollars to local charities or churches or whatever will help more people sooner and better than any program from a government.
User avatar
lukeyrid13
All-American
Posts: 10475
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:58 am
GM: Portland TrailBlazers

Re: Is there time for PAC 12 to change the mind?

Post by lukeyrid13 »

Quietduck wrote:It a financial fact that the larger the organization the less efficient it is in distributing support in any format. The giant aid societies eat up over 90% of the contributions before distribution. The government is even worse just check social security or medicare. The only effective way to support anyone in need is to do it at the lowest possible level. States would be better than Federal. Counties would be better than states. Cities.... The best support system to distribute care is family and friends. Local charities would be next best. 1 million dollars to local charities or churches or whatever will help more people sooner and better than any program from a government.
^^^^ This 100%

It's maybe not the answer most want to hear, but it's sadly the unequivocal truth. Just paying more in taxes isn't a solution.

A good example is school districts. Many of the school districts with the highest per student cost, have some of the worst: scores, ratings etc. When it comes to schools, the #1 factor is parent involvement. Both at school and in the home. You can give a kid 10 iPads, 3 Macbooks and pay the teacher 125k a year. But if the parents aren't involved and don't care and there is no structure at home, the child is in a very poor position to succeed.

Home school on the other hand leads to great success. It has ostensibly zero cost, 100% parent involvement and likely far less expensive technology.

Platitudes and throwing money at problems sounds nice in theory across the board, but isn't always the most practical.
User avatar
jBeavertonduck
Two Star Recruit
Posts: 187
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 1:34 pm

Re: Is there time for PAC 12 to change the mind?

Post by jBeavertonduck »

pezsez1 wrote:
Again, shudowns aren't going to help. You can't make decisions based on the chance of a vaccine, which is another discussion all together.
Shutdowns do help -- everywhere else but here, where our leaders are too incompetent to follow the blueprint of most of the rest of the world. The shutdowns should have been more helpful here, but our federal leaders (and many state governors) frittered away our sacrifices. That pisses me off greatly.

And yes, we can make decisions based on the promising info we've seen about vaccines. We have three or four vaccines in stage 3 trials and, so far, the results are incredibly promising. It's worth using restraint for a few more months if that means saving tens of thousands of lives.

Now, if we get to December and learn that all of these vaccines are failures? Then it's time to plan on proceeding without vaccine help... and hopefully, by then, we have federal leaders who can think a bit bigger about adapting to our new reality. The rest of the world is doing so much better than we are and it blows my mind that so many Americans are willing to settle for doing nothing.

Kind of related, but earlier OregonFanforLife was talking about how privileged it is to just say "shut it all down" and nothing else. It's just as privileged to expect everyone vulnerable to lock themselves in their rooms and stop working, stop caring for kids and grandkids, stop going on vacation, etc. Our economy isn't set up for older people (and especially people with health issues) to simply stop working, stay home, or rehome their children/dependents. Don't take this the wrong way, but we don't have nearly enough socialism in our capitalism for that to be a viable solution.
The problem that I see with the shutdowns is that they postpone the spread of the disease. To me, it makes no sense to put a hold on the entire country to prevent the spread of Covid when the only vulnerable part of the population are those that are above retirement age or have preexisting health issues. It would make much more sense to allow people to continue to provide for their families, children to continue their education, and society to proceed as usual.

Every year we have seasonal flues and colds. Every year we are warned to wash our hands, cover our coughs, and to stay home if we feel ill. This is the same advice we have been given with regard to Covid. Why is it so controversial that the small part of our population that is vulnerable be protected instead of trying to prevent the inevitable spread of a virus through the entire world population? The virus is not going to magically disappear, and vaccines certainly aren't 100% effective.

Personally, I would much rather have the opportunity to decide for myself what was an acceptable risk, and then decide what my action would be. I do not want my government making those decisions for me. I refuse to blame our leaders for people not following normal, common sense guidelines in not spreading the disease. At some point, personal responsibility has to come into our discussion.

I had Covid back in February, I caught it in an Airport in Hawaii. We have had five people in our business (out of eight total) test positive for the antibodies. In addition, our families have had it as well. We are all living proof that catching Covid isn't a death sentence (our age range is from 58 to 65).

Lastly, I don't understand what having "more socialism in our capitalism" would do to to solve anything. Do you mean health care? Perhaps you would elaborate more.

Thanks
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40727
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Is there time for PAC 12 to change the mind?

Post by UOducksTK1 »

jBeavertonduck wrote:
pezsez1 wrote:
Again, shudowns aren't going to help. You can't make decisions based on the chance of a vaccine, which is another discussion all together.
Shutdowns do help -- everywhere else but here, where our leaders are too incompetent to follow the blueprint of most of the rest of the world. The shutdowns should have been more helpful here, but our federal leaders (and many state governors) frittered away our sacrifices. That pisses me off greatly.

And yes, we can make decisions based on the promising info we've seen about vaccines. We have three or four vaccines in stage 3 trials and, so far, the results are incredibly promising. It's worth using restraint for a few more months if that means saving tens of thousands of lives.

Now, if we get to December and learn that all of these vaccines are failures? Then it's time to plan on proceeding without vaccine help... and hopefully, by then, we have federal leaders who can think a bit bigger about adapting to our new reality. The rest of the world is doing so much better than we are and it blows my mind that so many Americans are willing to settle for doing nothing.

Kind of related, but earlier OregonFanforLife was talking about how privileged it is to just say "shut it all down" and nothing else. It's just as privileged to expect everyone vulnerable to lock themselves in their rooms and stop working, stop caring for kids and grandkids, stop going on vacation, etc. Our economy isn't set up for older people (and especially people with health issues) to simply stop working, stay home, or rehome their children/dependents. Don't take this the wrong way, but we don't have nearly enough socialism in our capitalism for that to be a viable solution.
The problem that I see with the shutdowns is that they postpone the spread of the disease. To me, it makes no sense to put a hold on the entire country to prevent the spread of Covid when the only vulnerable part of the population are those that are above retirement age or have preexisting health issues. It would make much more sense to allow people to continue to provide for their families, children to continue their education, and society to proceed as usual.

Every year we have seasonal flues and colds. Every year we are warned to wash our hands, cover our coughs, and to stay home if we feel ill. This is the same advice we have been given with regard to Covid. Why is it so controversial that the small part of our population that is vulnerable be protected instead of trying to prevent the inevitable spread of a virus through the entire world population? The virus is not going to magically disappear, and vaccines certainly aren't 100% effective.

Personally, I would much rather have the opportunity to decide for myself what was an acceptable risk, and then decide what my action would be. I do not want my government making those decisions for me. I refuse to blame our leaders for people not following normal, common sense guidelines in not spreading the disease. At some point, personal responsibility has to come into our discussion.

I had Covid back in February, I caught it in an Airport in Hawaii. We have had five people in our business (out of eight total) test positive for the antibodies. In addition, our families have had it as well. We are all living proof that catching Covid isn't a death sentence (our age range is from 58 to 65).

Lastly, I don't understand what having "more socialism in our capitalism" would do to to solve anything. Do you mean health care? Perhaps you would elaborate more.

Thanks
Glad you are all doing well!

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
RanDux
Senior
Posts: 2840
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:19 pm
Location: Happy Valley, OR

Re: Is there time for PAC 12 to change the mind?

Post by RanDux »

pezsez1 wrote:
This is the one thing the Pac-12 got right. Shutdown. Clear, concise reasons, with medical findings to support what they did and decent transparency.

I hate it. I'm already getting depressed about it...but just given what we're already seeing across college campuses, we had to do it.

Do I think there were viable solutions? Bubble situations? etc? Sure...but unless we started working on those in like February, we weren't going to get all those logistics arranged.
Agreed.

Also, let's be real: This isn't the Pac-12's fault. This is a result of piss-poor leadership that worked to discourage masks and social distancing while refusing to help states get the supplies and infrastructure needed for aggressive testing and contact tracing. No other country needs to build "bubbles" to keep people safe. We collectively ignored COVID and, big shock, it didn't magically go away.

And, for another big shock, COVID is now exploding at campuses that are opening. Gasp. Who could have predicted this.

We made our bed, and now we get to lie in it. Americans could have made simple lifestyle changes months ago to drive COVID into the ground, but we chose not to. We had more than enough time -- and the luxury of seeing what has worked in other countries -- and we frittered it away.

Actions have consequences.
Part of the blame goes to the American public. I work in a large supermarket, and all day long young and old alike move in right next to me while I am working to get product without giving me a warning to move out of the way. When I say something, they simply say, "You're okay." If I say, "No, we need to maintain a 6 foot distance," they usually give me a "Whatever" look, and walk away. We see this same careless attitude in the many protests, in social gatherings especially among the young, etc... The American public simply has not taken this pandemic seriously;
User avatar
Phalanx
All Pac-12
Posts: 5317
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:50 pm

Re: Is there time for PAC 12 to change the mind?

Post by Phalanx »

RanDux wrote: Part of the blame goes to the American public. I work in a large supermarket, and all day long young and old alike move in right next to me while I am working to get product without giving me a warning to move out of the way. When I say something, they simply say, "You're okay." If I say, "No, we need to maintain a 6 foot distance," they usually give me a "Whatever" look, and walk away. We see this same careless attitude in the many protests, in social gatherings especially among the young, etc... The American public simply has not taken this pandemic seriously;


So, after you rebuff someone for not observing the arbitrary distance requirements, what, in your mind, should they do rather than walk away from you? Are these offending patrons wearing masks while in your store? It seems highly doubtful that anyone would pass COVID to you in the situation you describe, especially if they are wearing a mask. They are probably more at risk from getting it from one of the shopping carts.

I rarely go to grocery stores - thankfully my wife does most of the shopping, and we are growing and picking more of our food this year than usual. I went last weekend on the spur of the moment, and was taken aback by how rude people are if one doesn't know the terrain. It was downright oppressive. It would be one thing if Oregon was full of COVID and we had people in the streets with wheelbarrows calling for us to bring out our dead, but dude, that isn't the situation here, like at all. It seems like the rudeness is over the top and unnecessary. Just speaking from my perspective, it feels like businesses that cater to the public need to figure out a way to gently or at least politely remind people about requirements that most of us don't have to observe anywhere else.
GoDucksIn09
Senior
Posts: 3086
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:15 am

Re: Is there time for PAC 12 to change the mind?

Post by GoDucksIn09 »

I am not going to make this political. There are enough people on here that want to make it all about politics. Some think that it will go all away after November. I highly doubt that but think it will achieve the purpose of those who want to make this the political issue of the year. That being said, I work in a drug store and am considered an essential worker. I see the whole spectrum of people. I see people who think they are the police and if a person's mask has slipped they act like they are public enemy number 1. I see people who even though remind them have to weak a mask in the store, after giving them a mask, come back in 5 minutes later not wearing the mask gave them 5 minutes ago. Society as a whole on BOTH SIDES done poorly on this whole thing. I said this awhile back with the whole toilet paper thing that people only think about themselves and nobody else. I refuse to make this a political thing. I see people from both sides not doing what they are being asked to do. This is not a right vs left issue. I know some here who want to kick and scream and insist that it is. I deal with the people every day. I don't get paid enough to deal with all these people and put my life at risk every day by dealing with these people. I do it though because I have to work and pay my bills and am happily married. I have to do my part as a guy. I don't read this thread often because like so many threads lately it is all political and very little to deal with the original thread. I wonder how long it will be before the threads are actually about the subject and not about politics. Maybe after November it will return to that. I suspect if one side does not get there way it will continue though. It use to be we had other rooms created for topics not related to the thread. Nowadays every thread seems to be about politics. It is why I do not post much anymore. I don't listen to the news or read newspapers because it is all political. My wife who is not from this country has little use for the news here and I don't have a problem with that.
User avatar
ncduck
Senior
Posts: 2189
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 7:14 am
Location: Rancho Palos Verdes, CA

Re: Is there time for PAC 12 to change the mind?

Post by ncduck »

In other news, the B1G is looking at a couple of return to play scenarios. The soonest is late November and the other is starting around New Year's.
User avatar
greenyellow
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 39373
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
Location: Eugene, OR

Re: Is there time for PAC 12 to change the mind?

Post by greenyellow »

ncduck wrote:In other news, the B1G is looking at a couple of return to play scenarios. The soonest is late November and the other is starting around New Year's.
Seems most of the options are having the teams play in domed stadiums to avoid playing in bad weather but that has its own set of pitfalls. Not sure that same kind of option exists for the Pac-12, especially for the Pacific Northwest and Mountain schools.
Image
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6482
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Is there time for PAC 12 to change the mind?

Post by pezsez1 »

I think the Pac-12 and Big 10 need to launch their seasons together. Make the Rose Bowl the ultimate prize, and maybe even hold a couple of other bowl games for second- and third-place finishers. Ignore the CFP.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
User avatar
greenyellow
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 39373
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
Location: Eugene, OR

Re: Is there time for PAC 12 to change the mind?

Post by greenyellow »

Problem with making the Rose Bowl the ultimate prize for the Big Ten and Pac-12 this season is that it's one of the CFP semifinal games.
Image
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40727
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Is there time for PAC 12 to change the mind?

Post by UOducksTK1 »

Already looking forward to the 2021 season and not even caring about the 2020 season.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
RanDux
Senior
Posts: 2840
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:19 pm
Location: Happy Valley, OR

Re: Is there time for PAC 12 to change the mind?

Post by RanDux »

Phalanx wrote:
RanDux wrote: Part of the blame goes to the American public. I work in a large supermarket, and all day long young and old alike move in right next to me while I am working to get product without giving me a warning to move out of the way. When I say something, they simply say, "You're okay." If I say, "No, we need to maintain a 6 foot distance," they usually give me a "Whatever" look, and walk away. We see this same careless attitude in the many protests, in social gatherings especially among the young, etc... The American public simply has not taken this pandemic seriously;


So, after you rebuff someone for not observing the arbitrary distance requirements, what, in your mind, should they do rather than walk away from you? Are these offending patrons wearing masks while in your store? It seems highly doubtful that anyone would pass COVID to you in the situation you describe, especially if they are wearing a mask. They are probably more at risk from getting it from one of the shopping carts.

I rarely go to grocery stores - thankfully my wife does most of the shopping, and we are growing and picking more of our food this year than usual. I went last weekend on the spur of the moment, and was taken aback by how rude people are if one doesn't know the terrain. It was downright oppressive. It would be one thing if Oregon was full of COVID and we had people in the streets with wheelbarrows calling for us to bring out our dead, but dude, that isn't the situation here, like at all. It seems like the rudeness is over the top and unnecessary. Just speaking from my perspective, it feels like businesses that cater to the public need to figure out a way to gently or at least politely remind people about requirements that most of us don't have to observe anywhere else.
My whole point is that most of the American public does not feel the need to socially distance, and that is partly what has gotten the U.S. in the mess it is in compared to most other countries.
Locked