pezsez1 wrote:Again, shudowns aren't going to help. You can't make decisions based on the chance of a vaccine, which is another discussion all together.
Shutdowns do help -- everywhere else but here, where our leaders are too incompetent to follow the blueprint of most of the rest of the world. The shutdowns should have been more helpful here, but our federal leaders (and many state governors) frittered away our sacrifices. That pisses me off greatly.
And yes, we can make decisions based on the promising info we've seen about vaccines. We have three or four vaccines in stage 3 trials and, so far, the results are incredibly promising. It's worth using restraint for a few more months if that means saving tens of thousands of lives.
Now, if we get to December and learn that all of these vaccines are failures? Then it's time to plan on proceeding without vaccine help... and hopefully, by then, we have federal leaders who can think a bit bigger about adapting to our new reality. The rest of the world is doing so much better than we are and it blows my mind that so many Americans are willing to settle for doing nothing.
Kind of related, but earlier OregonFanforLife was talking about how privileged it is to just say "shut it all down" and nothing else. It's just as privileged to expect everyone vulnerable to lock themselves in their rooms and stop working, stop caring for kids and grandkids, stop going on vacation, etc. Our economy isn't set up for older people (and especially people with health issues) to simply stop working, stay home, or rehome their children/dependents. Don't take this the wrong way, but we don't have nearly enough socialism in our capitalism for that to be a viable solution.
Disagree on your first few points. It's poor planning to place your hope in a vaccine that is being rushed through trials. People's livelihoods can't wait a few more months to finally
start planning for the inevitable. Shutdowns only help to prolong the suffering of communities that are living off of crumbs at this point because there are no jobs for them.
"It's just as privileged to expect everyone vulnerable to lock themselves in their rooms and stop working, stop caring for kids and grandkids, stop going on vacation, etc. Our economy isn't set up for older people (and especially people with health issues) to simply stop working, stay home, or rehome their children/dependents."
I didn't say anything about locking the elderly in their houses. It is the responsible thing to care for the elderly/health issues and to keep them out of society for safety purposes. Obviously, I'm against any sort of requirement from the government to enforce this, but it's just common sense. What is not common sense is causing damage/hurt to the rest of society by shutting down cities.
Short rant:
I'm all for socialism, if that means taking care of the poor/downcast. However, history has shown that government entities are (1) ill equipped with taking care of other people - governments are usually one of the worst-run organizations in America. Not a good idea to have them run social programs (2) governments have motives that are not for the ultimate good of the poor/downcast, but are heavily influenced by the temptation to retain power.
Our political system was designed with the concept that people were "good" and that the good people would take care of the lonely/downcast. See all of the amazing charities that were set up by people with amazing drive/ambition to take care of the poor/hurt. That is so much better of a system because (1) those organizations are run well because they have expertise in the area that they are serving (2) motivations are pure.
Lastly, people are less inclined to show compassion to others when they themselves are in a state of crisis.